1995 – Lisa Rotunno
1996 – Alisa Caparso
1997 –
1998 – Erin Bartlett
1999 – Tara Savon
2000 –
2001 –
2002 –
2003 – Tami Nero
2004 –
2005 – Dana Donatelli
2006 – Jacque Schrader
2007 – Jacque Schrader
2008 – Stephanie Yankle
2009 – Chelsea Marrie
2010 – Jamie Hynes
2011 – Ashley Moore
2012 – Ashley Moore
2013 – Rachel Durbin
2014 –
2015 – Emily Partika
2016 – Maria Mangine
2017 – Angie Williams
2018 – Marah Bellis
2019 – Juliana Lellio
2020 – Lily Vari-Coppola